Thursday, June 29, 2006

Pilot-Defined Instrument Departures

If you fly small aircraft under Instrument Flight Rules (IFR), you may not be used to flying departure procedures or you may be used to flying the same ones each time you file IFR. You learned during your instrument training that these procedures all have the same goals: Keep pilots from running into obstructions right after takeoff and simplify the delivery of IFR clearances. Unfortunately, there is some confusion surrounding departure procedures because the terminology has changed back and forth. Add the way different GPS receivers handle departure procedures and matters are made more complicated. To my mind, there are four varieties of departure procedures: those devised by the pilot, Obstacle Departure Procedures, DPs, and SIDs. I'll discuss pilot-devised departure procedures in this installment.

Departing an airport in uncontrolled airspace (Class G in the U.S.) and for which there is no defined procedure, the pilot needs to do thorough planning. Let's say you're departing Shelter Cove, California for an IFR flight to San Jose. The IFR clearance you receive might sound something like this:
Bonanza 12345 is cleared to San Jose Mineta Airport via, when entering controlled airspace, direct Mendocino, Victor 27, Point Reyes One arrival ...
There are no instrument procedures defined for Shelter Cove, so use the appropriate VFR sectional and IFR low altitude en route charts, your knowledge of the local terrain, your aircraft's climb performance data, and some common sense to devise a strategy to climb to a safe altitude for vectors to Mendocino.



The Maximum Elevation Figure on the VFR sectional for the area where Shelter Cover is located is 4,400 feet. The Minimum Off-Route Obstruction Clearance Altitudes on the IFR low altitude en route chart sector for Shelter Cove is 6,400' with a MORCA of 5,000' for the sector to the south, and 9,800' to the East. The Minimum En route Altitude for V27 is 6,700'. The airspace surrounding Shelter Cove is Class G (uncontrolled) from the surface to 1200' AGL, with Class E (controlled airspace) beginning at 1200'. Should the ceiling at Shelter Cove be below 1200', keep in mind that after takeoff you will be operating in instrument conditions in Class G (uncontrolled) airspace until you climb to 1200' .

Departing runway 30 at Shelter Cove with a climbing left turn to heading 180 looks to be the way to go since there is quickly rising terrain to the north and to the east. The bad news is that the left turn takes you out over the Pacific Ocean, so it helps to have plenty of confidence in your aircraft. Here's what a G1000 would display on the ground at Shelter Cove.



If you're flying a G1000-equipped aircraft, now is the time to have the terrain feature enabled on the moving map. Whenever you see red on the terrain display, there is terrain less than 100' from your current altitude. Yellow means terra firma is between 100' and 1000' of your altitude. The absence of any colors (or black, if you have the topographic data turned off) means you're more than 1000' above terrain. If you have a hand-held GPS that displays terrain data, don't use it for primary navigation but by all means use it to enhance your situational awareness. Here is the PFD with the inset map in the lower left side of the screen set to show terrain data.



Here's what the PFD might look like climbing out from runway 30 at Shelter Cove.



As you begin the left turn toward the Mendocino VOR and begin to gain altitude, you'll begin to see more yellow than red on the terrain display.



Intercepting the direct course to the VOR, almost all of the yellow and red have disappeared.



If you plan to depart VFR and pick up your clearance airborne, the weather conditions should allow you to climb to a sufficient altitude to establish radio communications with the ATC facility that provides departure control for the area. The last thing you want is to get airborne in deteriorating weather only to find you can't raise ATC on the radio or that ATC can't identify you on radar to issue your clearance. Due to terrain and the remote nature of the location, Oakland Center has limited radio and radar coverage in this area, so your best bet would be to call Flight Service on the phone to get your IFR clearance while still on the ground at Shelter Cove. Last time I was at Shelter Cove (about a year ago), my cell phone couldn't get a signal, but there is a pay phone nearby. You can see why they call this area The Lost Coast.

6 comments:

Eric Gideon said...

I'm a regular subscriber (and soon-to-be CFI student), and I really enjoy your writing. I'm curious - are you getting the G1000 screenshots from Garmin's cockpit trainer?

Ron said...

I've made a few of these pilot-defined departure procedures over the years. The coastal ones are such a breeze. My favorite is out of Oceano (near Pismo Beach). You takeoff and head right out over the water. An airway passes over the field, and an intersection is directly over the airport, so it was always easy to negotiate an instrument clearance that started there.

The only problems I ran into were controllers (few and far between) who didn't know how I could depart IFR when there was no published obstacle departure procedure. I would tell them I'd take responsibility for my own obstacle clearance, and they'd only grudgingly agree to give me the clearance, as though it would be impossible to stay out of the rocks without an FAA-approved procedure.

Pilot-designed departures are not something to mess with lightly, but in situations like the one at L52, they are a piece of cake.

John said...

Glad you're enjoying the blog, Eric. Yes, the screenshots are coming from the Garmin trainer. Version 6.1 as I recall. These PC based trainers have problems, which is why one of the screen shots shows a greater than standard rate turn. Garmin periodically updates this trainer, but I don't know of any way to find out about updates other than to contact them directly. Then you have to pay another $4 plus shipping to get the disk. Wish they had an update program, but I understand there are export issues with the software.

I'm with you Ron. Done properly, pilot-defined departures increase the utility of a small plane.

RJ Wannabe said...

John,

You're like my internet instructor. It's funny, alot of your posts parallel what I'm working on in instrument right now. I really appreciate your comments and check your site often.

Thanks for blogging for the sake of student pilots.

Mike

Jim Howard said...

Every time I've taken off IFR from an uncontrolled airport I've been given an instruction to "enter controlled airspace heading XXX".

Is that not the universial practice?

John said...

Jim,

I'm not an air traffic controller, but my reading of the section on departure clearances in Order 7110.65R "Air Traffic Control" indicates that controllers are not to issue a heading or direction of turn for aircraft departing an airport where class E airspace does not extend to the surface.

In my experience, controllers are very careful to specify the published obstacle departure procedure in a clearance when a pilot is departing a airport surrounded by nasty terrain. The example I gave is an oddball case because there is no such procedure, but it is a situation that GA pilots can encounter.

Not to put too fine a point on it, there are no uncontrolled airports in the U.S., only airports in uncontrolled airspace. Air traffic at non-towered airports is governed by the appropriate regulations concerning right-of-way as well as the practices described in the AIM and advisory circular AC90-66A. The only difference is that the pilots are applying these rules instead of having a controller tell them what to do.